• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Association for Academic Surgery (AAS)

  • Home
  • About
    • AAS Staff
    • Contact Us
    • Foundation
  • Membership
    • Apply For Membership
    • New Member List
    • Membership Directory
    • Check Dues Balance / Pay Dues
  • Jobs
    • AAS Job Board
    • Post a Job
  • Resources
    • Assistant Professor Playbook
    • Partners
    • AAS Resources
    • Resident Research Funding Primer
  • Grants/Awards
    • AAS/AASF Fall Courses Award
    • AAS/AASF Research Awards
      • Basic Science/Translational Research Award
      • Clinical Outcomes/Health Services Research Award
      • Trainee Research Fellowship Award in Education
      • Global Surgery Research Fellowship Award
      • Joel J. Roslyn Faculty Research Award
    • Travel Awards
      • AAS/AASF Student Diversity Travel Award
      • Senior Medical Student Travel Award
      • Visiting Professorships
    • Awards FAQ’s
  • Meetings
    • Academic Surgical Congress
    • Surgical Investigators’ Course
    • AAS Fall Courses
    • International Courses
      • Fundamentals of Surgical Research Course and Scientific Writing Workshop
    • Resident Research Funding Primer
  • Publications
  • Webinars
    • Fireside Chat – Maintaining Balance & Control
    • Diversity, Inclusion & Equity Series
      • Allyship
      • PRIDE: The LGBTQ+ Community in Academic Surgery
      • Racial Discrimination in Academic Surgery
    • Academic Surgery in the Time of COVID-19 Series
      • How to Optimize your Research During the Pandemic
      • How to Optimize Educational Experiences During the Pandemic
      • Virtual Interviews
    • The Transition to Practice – Presented by Intuitive
  • Leadership
    • Current AAS Leadership
    • AAS Past Presidents
    • How to Chair
    • Committee Missions & Objectives
    • AAS Officer Descriptions
  • Blog
    • Submit a Post
  • Log In

August 13, 2019 by Arpana Jain, MD

Practice Diversity in Academic Surgery

Recently I was sitting in the audience of a scientific session at a surgical society meeting. I heard tons of new things, new take on old things and bunch of science fiction-esque results from basic science labs. Of all the insights I gained, one stood out. A junior resident from a university affiliated residency program presented their experience after they applied a new best practice to their ICU. He mentioned conducting a study in their ‘Open ICU’; a surgical study that included patients from Medical ICU and Surgical ICU, a study that was limited by inability to bring all community providers on board. It reminded me of my time working in open ICUs in ‘non-academic’ hospitals.

There are 6210 hospitals in the US, of which 1100 are teaching hospitals. Only 120 are considered academic medical centers (AMC) and the rest are community or university affiliated1. The world outside AMCs presents unique challenges while pursuing evidence-based medicine. Demands of high volume case load, relationship with hospital and consultants, in fact, most surgical patients are admitted to hospitalist service. Workhorse community surgeons bring their perspective to the scientific forums. They spend most of their time at the front line of patient care and know first-hand the unmet needs. But do these surgeons get to participate the mission to innovate and advance clinical care?

I applaud the busy research center that take up challenges and find answers while others are busy using that info to improve lives at the front line. However, a few large academic programs disproportionately contribute to most medical innovation. This was also evident in the meeting I was attending. Almost two-third of the talks and posters were sourced from less than 10 institutions. Similar to any other matter of diversity and inclusion, having diverse perspectives brings in new ideas and enriches the conversation. I was intrigued while listening to a study by a junior resident in an open ICU. It is especially important in this day and age where many outcome scientists are churning large databases and finding associations that were hitherto difficult to unearth. We need input from the non-academic clinicians to frame such questions that are relevant to everyone. This also applies to multi-center trials that are promoted and supported by surgical societies. The ‘multi’ in the multi-center demands diversity to include not just traditional academic centers but also community hospitals and private surgeons, such that their result can be applied to all practice settings. So, is there a problem of diversity of practice in academic surgery? I want to say yes. We need inclusion of surgeons from all practice settings, large AMC to private practice, to ensure comprehensive and relevant surgical education and research. We sort of do that in surgical training already by including ‘diverse’ rotations.

How do we achieve this inclusion? Whose responsibility is it to get all stakeholders on the table when discussing the next big problem? Academic surgeons are always on this table; it is part of their mission. How about the private or ‘acad affiliated’ surgeons? Is it that they are simply not interested in solving the problem they face every day? And if they are interested, then does everyone get same opportunity for scientific productivity? I see a large gap between haves and have nots when it comes to academic resources, time and funding. I believe that it is not just the lack of desire. Society sends its most brilliant minds to serve in medicine. There is a pipeline of academic surgery, that runs from schools offering more than one degree at graduation, to the large 5+n years residency program with mandatory research time to fellowships. It usually ends at an academic job ripe with all the bells and whistles one needs to run the next big trial or fully funded lab. Obviously, students who choose and worked hard for dual degrees have earned themselves a spot on that stream. But students or residents who missed that pedigree train may also offer clever solutions. They will most certainly treat a large number of patients and may or may not want to adopt the new advancement coming out the university next door. We need all to make surgical care, education and research whole.

I wonder what academic inclusion would look like. Having more speakers out of community hospitals at surgical meetings to glean from their experience? Collaborating with private surgeons, providing resources like time, funding or infrastructure? Incentives for scientific society memberships and attendance? Asking for their input while designing studies and making it easier for a private doc to include their patients (read collaborate)? What would be a good proportion of community centers in multi-center clinical trial so the results are applicable to all? At the very least, we ought to talk about academic practice diversity and acknowledge the disparities. Here, I am doing my part.

Reference:

  1. American Hospital Association
  • Bio
  • Latest Posts

Arpana Jain, MD

Arpana Jain is a Burn Doctor at the Arizona Burn Center. She is also an Assistant Professor of Surgery at Creighton University school of Medicine - Phoenix and University of Arizona College of Medicine - Phoenix. Her practice includes care for adult and pediatric burn as well as burn reconstruction. She serves on the AAS membership committee and promotes wider reach of academic surgery.

Latest posts by Arpana Jain, MD (see all)

  • Practice Diversity in Academic Surgery - August 13, 2019

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

Other Posts from The Academic Surgeon:

2019 Young Investigators Award
The Urgent Need For Compassion in the Healthcare Workplace

Primary Sidebar

Log In

  • Lost your password?

AAS Commitment to Diversity in Academic Surgery

Save the Date: 2023 Academic Surgical Congress

Save the date for the 18th ASC!
February 7-9, 2023
Hilton Americas-Houston
Houston, TX
More information coming soon.  Learn more>>

2023 AAS Fall Courses

Save the Date! Saturday, October 21, 2023 Boston , MA Courses will take place immediately prior to the ACS Clinical … More Information » about Fall Courses

Footer

Association for Academic Surgery
11300 W. Olympic Blvd, Suite 600
Los Angeles, CA 90064
Phone: (310) 437-1606
Email: [email protected]

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

© 2023 · AAS - Association for Academic Surgery