• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Association for Academic Surgery (AAS)

  • Home
  • About
    • AAS Staff
    • Contact Us
    • Foundation
  • Membership
    • Apply For Membership
    • New Member List
    • Membership Directory
    • Check Dues Balance / Pay Dues
  • Jobs
    • AAS Job Board
    • Post a Job
  • Resources
    • Assistant Professor Playbook
    • Partners
    • AAS Resources
    • Resident Research Funding Primer
  • Grants/Awards
    • AAS/AASF Fall Courses Award
    • AAS/AASF Research Awards
      • Basic Science/Translational Research Award
      • Clinical Outcomes/Health Services Research Award
      • Trainee Research Fellowship Award in Education
      • Global Surgery Research Fellowship Award
      • Joel J. Roslyn Faculty Research Award
    • Travel Awards
      • AAS/AASF Student Diversity Travel Award
      • Senior Medical Student Travel Award
      • Visiting Professorships
    • Awards FAQ’s
  • Meetings
    • Academic Surgical Congress
    • Surgical Investigators’ Course
    • AAS Fall Courses
    • International Courses
      • Fundamentals of Surgical Research Course and Scientific Writing Workshop
    • Resident Research Funding Primer
  • Publications
  • Webinars
    • Fireside Chat – Maintaining Balance & Control
    • Diversity, Inclusion & Equity Series
      • Allyship
      • PRIDE: The LGBTQ+ Community in Academic Surgery
      • Racial Discrimination in Academic Surgery
    • Academic Surgery in the Time of COVID-19 Series
      • How to Optimize your Research During the Pandemic
      • How to Optimize Educational Experiences During the Pandemic
      • Virtual Interviews
    • The Transition to Practice – Presented by Intuitive
  • Leadership
    • Current AAS Leadership
    • AAS Past Presidents
    • How to Chair
    • Committee Missions & Objectives
    • AAS Officer Descriptions
  • Blog
    • Submit a Post
  • Log In

May 28, 2015 by Melissa Hogg

Revisiting “Why Johnny Cannot Operate”

What goes around comes around. I did my general surgery residency at Northwestern University in Chicago, IL. Looking back I can see how hard they worked to systematically try to educate us inside and outside of the operating room; especially outside. I remember feeling that the mandatory lectures and skill sessions were detracting from my potential education with patients on the floor or in the operating room. Now, on the other side of that relationship, trying to educate trainees, I have a new appreciation of what it takes to prepare a surgeon and I want to find where all the barriers are located.

After graduating [not during training] from residency and leaving Northwestern, I realized how lucky I was to have received such great training and really wanted to make medical education an important component to my practice. Upon clinical appointment, I pursued a master’s degree in medical education at the University of Pittsburgh and in my “Innovative Teaching Strategies” class, this paper “Why Johnny Cannot Operate” was among our assigned reading. This article was written by the former Northwestern Chair of Surgery, Dr. Richard Bell, after he retired from clinical practice and joined the American Board of Surgery to develop further education pursuits for surgical residents via Score.

When I read this, I was amazed by how timely it is, how much I agreed with it, and could not believe it was written 6 years ago from the person who recruited me as a medical student. I think it was a little ahead of its time because we are not yet at a point where these suggestions are a reality. In this paper Bell discusses Dr. Ericsson’s “10,000” hours to develop expertise and asserts the following, based on analysis of ACGME case logs. The average resident spends 1,148 hours during a 5 year residency doing essential operations (a list of 121 determined by program directors) and possibly 2,753 hours if you include all operative time beyond the essentials. Most notably mentioned is that the mode on 63 of the 121 essential operations is “0” and that across the country there is concern about the operative skill set of residents at the time of graduation.

Compounding these challenges have been the increased work hour restrictions, increased fellowship positions, technology advancement, oversight, quality assurance and quality initiatives (QAQI), cost and efficiency concerns, increased malpractice lawsuits, and also, generational changes in the demographics of trainees. We are no longer training Baby Boomers, not that I was ever one myself, but Millennials are different. Many of us pursue surgery because of the immediate gratification of fixing a problem: instantly opening a blocked artery, instantly repairing a perforation, or instantly removing a tumor. However, surgical training does not lend itself to instant gratification. We all know we cannot obtain the necessary skill sets to perform these operations “instantly”. For me, “instantly” is 11 years and counting since graduating medical school because, unfortunately, surgery and medicine is humbling in that it constantly shows us we do not know everything.   While we all learned the dogma “see one, do one, teach one” it is pretty clear that this is not a viable strategy for training surgeons in the modern era.

Dr. Bell in his article makes 8 recommendations for how to move past this paradigm and train Johnny to operate:

  1. Insist on accurate national data on operative experience of residents
  2. Do interim evaluations of resident operative experience
  3. Change the required standards for case experience
  4. Make operative skill a required competency for board certification of surgeons and develop tools to assess it
  5. Study and improve teaching in the operating room
  6. Develop a pedagogic scheme for teaching operations
  7. Develop validated, standardized assessment tools for resident performance in the operating room
  8. Move the simulation agenda forward with a national consortium

I know. It sounds like a lot of time and expense.  However, I portend there are individuals out there working on each of these recommendations in some form completely independent of ever having read this article. Personally, I am working toward trying to establish predictive validity for robotic hepatobiliary training using proficiency based virtual reality simulation, deliberate practice high fidelity inanimate models, video teaching, and operative scoring real time and via video. It is a tremendous amount of work for what may seem like a narrow application. However, it is a paradigmatic shift in the way we are training HPB/SSO fellows in complex foregut surgery. Already we have seen tangible return with an immediate increase in the number of trainees able to complete the very complex task of robotic pancreaticoduodenectomy. I would propose by joining forces as a society where each educator brings their niche, the Association of Academic Surgeons could become a forum to showcase and disseminate an innovative pathway to high quality, high fidelity surgical education.

Bell says, “In an ideal, future world, I would suggest that a resident would come to the operating room having undergone both cognitive training and skills training in the procedure to be performed.” This seems like a simple request and absolutely necessary, but do we feel this is currently being achieved? If not, it should be, and as academic surgeons it is our calling to work towards this for our patients and our pupils.

  • Bio
  • Latest Posts

Melissa Hogg

Dr. Melissa E. Hogg, MD is an Assistant Professor in the Division of Gastrointestinal Surgical Oncology at the University of Pittsburgh. She is board certified in general surgery and complex general surgical oncology and her practice specializes in minimally invasive benign and malignant diseases of the stomach, bile duct, pancreas, colon, and rectum. She completed her medical school and residency at Northwestern University in Chicago and completed her surgical oncology fellowship and degrees in Medical Education and Clinical Research at the University of Pittsburgh.

Latest posts by Melissa Hogg (see all)

  • Revisiting “Why Johnny Cannot Operate” - May 28, 2015

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

Other Posts from The Academic Surgeon:

New Initiative from The Association for Surgical Education
Mobile Technology Integrated into Surgical Care: Daydream, Nightmare or Reality?

Primary Sidebar

Log In

  • Lost your password?

AAS Commitment to Diversity in Academic Surgery

Save the Date: 2023 Academic Surgical Congress

Save the date for the 18th ASC!
February 7-9, 2023
Hilton Americas-Houston
Houston, TX
More information coming soon.  Learn more>>

2023 AAS Fall Courses

Save the Date! Saturday, October 21, 2023 Boston , MA Courses will take place immediately prior to the ACS Clinical … More Information » about Fall Courses

Footer

Association for Academic Surgery
11300 W. Olympic Blvd, Suite 600
Los Angeles, CA 90064
Phone: (310) 437-1606
Email: [email protected]

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

© 2023 · AAS - Association for Academic Surgery